Key Takeaways
-
Medicare Advantage plans with poor star ratings, high prior authorization rates, and narrow networks often create obstacles to timely, affordable care.
-
Recognizing red flags early, such as misleading marketing, unclear cost structures, or dropped providers, can help you avoid enrolling in a plan that doesn’t meet your healthcare needs.
What Sets the Worst Medicare Advantage Plans Apart?
At first glance, many Medicare Advantage plans appear similar. They may promise low monthly premiums and added benefits like dental or vision care. But if you look closer, some plans come with hidden issues that can significantly disrupt your access to care.
The worst Medicare Advantage plans are those that sound appealing in brochures but come with serious coverage limitations, high out-of-pocket costs, or problematic customer service. These plans may not technically violate any regulations, yet they still fall short of meeting the real needs of enrollees.
1. Low Star Ratings Shouldn’t Be Ignored
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) evaluates Medicare Advantage plans annually and assigns star ratings from 1 to 5, with 5 being excellent. Plans receiving fewer than 3 stars for multiple consecutive years are a major red flag.
Plans with low star ratings often:
-
Score poorly in customer satisfaction
-
Struggle with member complaints and appeals
-
Perform below average in managing chronic conditions
-
Receive low marks in customer service and call center response
A low rating indicates systemic issues that could affect your experience. While one poor year may not be disqualifying, consistent underperformance is a serious warning.
2. High Rates of Prior Authorization Delays and Denials
In 2025, prior authorizations remain a common feature of many Medicare Advantage plans. While they are meant to ensure care is medically necessary, high volumes of prior authorization requirements are a hallmark of poorly rated plans.
Watch out for plans that:
-
Require prior approval for a long list of services, including common diagnostic tests or outpatient procedures
-
Deny authorizations at a higher-than-average rate
-
Delay authorizations, leading to postponed care
Delays in care can worsen medical conditions or leave you scrambling to find alternative providers. The best plans streamline prior authorizations, while the worst use them to manage costs at the expense of timely care.
3. Limited Provider Networks
The worst Medicare Advantage plans typically have narrow provider networks, which means fewer doctors, specialists, and hospitals are covered.
This can lead to:
-
Long travel distances to reach in-network providers
-
Difficulty scheduling timely appointments
-
Surprise bills when providers drop out mid-year
A plan that doesn’t include your preferred doctors or facilities may leave you feeling stuck or force you to switch care providers altogether. Even worse, if a doctor leaves the network during the year, you might lose access without warning.
4. Aggressive or Misleading Marketing Tactics
Some plans use vague or overly promotional marketing to attract new enrollees. These tactics are often geared toward emphasizing low premiums while omitting crucial details about coverage limitations, copayments, or drug formularies.
Red flags include:
-
Generic language that promises everything without specifics
-
Failure to clearly explain costs, like deductibles or coinsurance
-
Pressure to enroll quickly without time to compare options
In recent years, CMS has stepped up enforcement against misleading advertisements. Still, many plans skirt the edge of what’s permissible. If a plan’s marketing feels too good to be true, take a closer look.
5. Poor Prescription Drug Coverage
Although Medicare Part D drug coverage is often included in Medicare Advantage plans, the scope and quality of that coverage vary widely. Some of the worst plans:
-
Have restrictive formularies that exclude common or brand-name drugs
-
Charge higher-than-average copayments for preferred drugs
-
Place frequently used medications in higher cost tiers
In 2025, Medicare Part D now includes a $2,000 annual out-of-pocket cap for prescription drugs. However, poor-quality plans may still expose you to high upfront costs or limit your access to necessary medications through tiered pricing and step therapy requirements.
6. Poor Customer Service and Appeals Process
A plan’s support system can make or break your experience. If you can’t get timely help or resolve disputes efficiently, you may end up paying more or delaying care.
Signs of poor service include:
-
Long wait times when calling member services
-
Denials that are not clearly explained
-
A slow, confusing appeals process for denied claims
Plans that don’t prioritize customer service tend to frustrate enrollees and receive poor reviews, which directly impacts their star ratings as well.
7. Unclear Cost-Sharing Rules
Even though some plans promote lower premiums, hidden costs can quickly add up. The worst plans often bury details in fine print or provide confusing language around out-of-pocket costs.
Examples of unclear or burdensome cost-sharing include:
-
High copays for routine services like physical therapy or diagnostic imaging
-
Excessive coinsurance percentages for hospital stays or outpatient surgery
-
Poor transparency around out-of-pocket maximums
In 2025, Medicare Advantage plans have a maximum out-of-pocket (MOOP) limit of $9,350 for in-network care and $14,000 for combined in- and out-of-network services. Some plans come close to these limits while appearing inexpensive upfront.
8. Frequent Changes to Benefits and Networks
One key indicator of an unreliable plan is how often it changes its benefits, provider networks, or drug coverage.
Frequent changes may mean:
-
Benefits like dental, vision, or over-the-counter allowances suddenly disappear
-
Doctors and specialists drop from the plan, sometimes without prior notice
-
Drug coverage tiers shift, increasing costs for common medications
These changes can occur every year during the Annual Enrollment Period (October 15 to December 7), leaving you scrambling to evaluate options before the new year begins.
9. Poor Performance in Chronic Condition Management
Many Medicare Advantage enrollees live with chronic conditions such as diabetes, heart disease, or COPD. Good plans offer structured disease management programs. The worst plans, on the other hand, often:
-
Lack proper care coordination
-
Provide insufficient follow-up or preventive services
-
Score poorly in CMS chronic care metrics
If a plan doesn’t have solid support for chronic condition management, you may end up needing more emergency or inpatient care—both of which are more expensive.
10. Lack of Plan Transparency During Enrollment
When you’re trying to choose a plan, transparency is critical. The worst plans often withhold or obscure key information until after enrollment.
This may include:
-
Missing provider directories during plan comparisons
-
Incomplete drug formularies
-
Vague or unlisted copayments for important services
Any plan that makes it difficult to understand your coverage upfront may leave you dealing with costly surprises later.
How to Protect Yourself When Comparing Plans
You can avoid these pitfalls by focusing on transparency, verified performance metrics, and reviewing plan documents thoroughly. Take these actions:
-
Review CMS Star Ratings at Medicare.gov
-
Check provider directories to confirm your doctors are in-network
-
Look at the plan’s Summary of Benefits and Evidence of Coverage
-
Be cautious with marketing calls or ads that don’t provide specific plan details
-
Consult with a licensed agent listed on this website for an unbiased comparison
Staying Ahead of These Medicare Advantage Pitfalls
In 2025, Medicare Advantage plans continue to evolve, but not always for the better. If you’re considering switching plans or enrolling for the first time, paying attention to these red flags can save you stress, money, and health complications.
Avoiding plans with low star ratings, hidden costs, narrow provider networks, and unclear drug coverage is key to protecting your well-being. A plan that works for someone else may not work for you—especially if it glosses over critical coverage details.
Take time to compare your options carefully, and reach out to a licensed agent listed on this website for personalized advice before you enroll.
