What to Watch for When Comparing the Best Medicare Advantage Plans in Your Area

Key Takeaways

• Medicare Advantage plans vary significantly by location, so comparing local options is essential to find the most suitable plan for your healthcare needs.

• Star Ratings from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) provide a quick reference for plan quality but should not be the only factor in your decision.

Understanding Medicare Advantage in 2025

Medicare Advantage, also known as Medicare Part C, continues to be a popular alternative to Original Medicare in 2025. These plans are offered through private insurance companies approved by Medicare, and they typically bundle hospital (Part A), medical (Part B), and sometimes prescription drug coverage (Part D) into one package. Many plans also include extra benefits like dental, vision, hearing, and fitness programs.

While these plans are regulated by Medicare, the benefits, costs, and provider networks vary widely based on the area you live in. That makes comparing plans in your specific ZIP code more important than ever.

The Role of CMS Star Ratings

The CMS evaluates and scores Medicare Advantage plans annually using a Star Rating system, ranging from 1 to 5 stars:

• 5 stars: Excellent

• 4 stars: Above average

• 3 stars: Average

• 2 stars: Below average

• 1 star: Poor

These ratings are based on multiple performance metrics, including member experience, customer service, management of chronic conditions, and preventive care. Although a plan with 4 or 5 stars may seem ideal, it’s crucial to look beyond the rating and evaluate how well the plan fits your specific healthcare needs.

Coverage Differences Across States and Counties

A Medicare Advantage plan available in one area might not be offered in another. Even plans with the same name can include different provider networks, benefits, or costs based on geography. Here are some local factors that can influence plan availability:

• Urban vs. rural: Rural areas tend to have fewer provider networks and limited plan options.

• Provider contracts: Some doctors and hospitals only accept certain Medicare Advantage plans, which may vary by location.

• Healthcare demand and infrastructure: Local health services and population needs shape how plans are structured.

This makes it essential to compare local plans directly rather than relying on nationwide rankings or general recommendations.

What to Evaluate When Comparing Plans

To compare Medicare Advantage plans effectively, you’ll need to dig into the details. Here are the key areas to focus on:

1. Monthly Premiums and Out-of-Pocket Costs

Every plan has its own pricing structure. While some offer low premiums, they might come with high copayments or deductibles. Keep in mind:

• In-network vs. out-of-network costs

• Annual out-of-pocket maximum (in 2025, this limit is capped at $9,350 for in-network care)

• Cost-sharing for specialist visits, hospital stays, and diagnostics

Always review the total expected cost of care, not just the monthly premium.

2. Network of Providers

A plan’s provider network determines which doctors, hospitals, and specialists you can see at lower costs. Before enrolling:

• Confirm your preferred providers are in-network.

• Understand whether the plan requires referrals to see specialists.

• Evaluate access to nearby healthcare facilities.

Narrow networks might save you money but could limit your access to care.

3. Prescription Drug Coverage

Most Medicare Advantage plans include Part D coverage. However, formularies (lists of covered drugs) can differ significantly between plans. You should:

• Check that your medications are included and at which tier.

• Compare copays for both generics and brand-name drugs.

• Understand coverage during the deductible, initial coverage, and catastrophic phases.

In 2025, Medicare Part D introduces a $2,000 cap on annual out-of-pocket drug costs, which is an important consideration.

4. Prior Authorization and Plan Rules

Many Medicare Advantage plans require prior authorization for services like imaging, surgeries, and rehabilitation. Understand these limitations:

• How often is prior authorization needed?

• How quickly are requests processed?

• What are the denial rates for common services?

Administrative hurdles can delay care if not reviewed beforehand.

5. Supplemental Benefits

Plans may offer extra benefits that go beyond Original Medicare. These can include:

• Dental and vision care

• Hearing aids

• Transportation to medical appointments

• Meal delivery

• Fitness memberships

Although attractive, you should verify:

• The actual value and scope of these benefits

• Any limitations or conditions for use

• If benefits change mid-year or require activation

6. Plan Stability and Changes Over Time

Plans change from year to year. Benefits, premiums, networks, and drug formularies can all shift. Use these strategies to stay informed:

• Review your Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) letter each fall

• Compare plan documents during the Open Enrollment Period (October 15 to December 7)

• Check your plan’s CMS Star Rating updates each year

Even a plan that worked well in 2024 might not meet your needs in 2025.

7. Travel and Nationwide Coverage

Some Medicare Advantage plans have geographic restrictions. If you travel frequently or split your time between two states:

• Check whether the plan includes nationwide emergency or urgent care coverage

• See if there’s a visitor/traveler program for temporary care in another region

• Consider if a PPO plan better suits your mobility than an HMO

Not all plans are designed for retirees with flexible lifestyles.

Special Enrollment Opportunities in 2025

In addition to the main enrollment window each fall, there are special times when you can change plans:

• Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period: January 1 to March 31

• Special Enrollment Periods (SEPs): Triggered by events like moving, loss of coverage, or plan termination

• 5-Star Special Enrollment: If a 5-star plan becomes available in your area, you may switch once between December 8 and November 30

Use these timelines strategically to adapt to changes in health or plan performance.

Why Regional Plan Comparison Matters More Than Ever

In 2025, the Medicare Advantage landscape is increasingly shaped by regional conditions. Plans are becoming more tailored to local provider networks, patient demographics, and health trends. This makes national advertising or rankings less relevant unless they’re filtered by ZIP code.

Also, variations in plan rules, such as step therapy for medications or service area restrictions, can significantly impact your experience. Relying on local comparisons ensures your decision reflects the real-world performance and coverage available to you.

How to Research Plans Effectively

Here’s how to approach your Medicare Advantage comparison process:

• Use the Medicare Plan Finder Tool to filter by ZIP code, provider network, and drug coverage

• Contact your local State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) for free support

• Schedule a consultation with a licensed agent listed on this website to get personalized advice

• Review each plan’s Summary of Benefits and Evidence of Coverage (EOC) documents before enrolling

Taking the time to do a thorough review helps avoid costly mistakes and ensures your plan fits your unique health and financial situation.

Make Your Medicare Advantage Comparison Count

When comparing Medicare Advantage plans in your area, it’s not just about finding the one with the most stars or the lowest monthly cost. It’s about identifying the plan that aligns with your doctors, prescriptions, lifestyle, and long-term health needs.

Evaluate each plan side by side using consistent metrics. Ask questions, use available tools, and make use of your right to switch during enrollment periods. And if it all feels overwhelming, don’t hesitate to speak with a licensed agent listed on this website. Their expertise can help you sort through the fine print and make a confident decision.