Key Takeaways
-
Medicare Part D plans may appear similar at first glance, but their drug coverage, cost-sharing rules, and pharmacy networks can differ significantly.
-
In 2025, understanding formularies, tiered pricing, and the new $2,000 out-of-pocket cap is essential when choosing a plan that aligns with your medication needs and financial goals.
Why Medicare Part D Requires a Closer Look
Medicare Part D is designed to offer prescription drug coverage, but just because plans fall under the same federal program doesn’t mean they offer the same benefits. While all Part D plans must meet minimum coverage standards set by Medicare, the actual drugs covered, pricing structure, and pharmacy access can vary widely.
In 2025, there are hundreds of plans available across the U.S., and while their brochures may look alike, what’s inside the plan matters more than ever.
What All Part D Plans Have in Common
Before exploring the differences, it’s important to know what unites all Medicare Part D plans:
-
They are offered by private insurance companies approved by Medicare.
-
They must follow federal guidelines for standard coverage.
-
They cover at least two drugs in each category and class of medication.
-
They must include coverage for most drugs in protected classes, such as antidepressants, antipsychotics, and cancer medications.
-
All plans now include the $2,000 annual out-of-pocket maximum, which took effect in 2025.
That said, the similarities often end at the surface. Once you examine a plan’s details, the variations become clear.
How Formularies Create Major Differences
A formulary is the list of prescription drugs a plan covers. Even though two plans may cover the same therapeutic class, one might include a specific drug you take, while the other does not—or requires prior authorization.
Plans update their formularies every year, often reclassifying drugs, adding new ones, or removing others. This means:
-
A drug you take today may not be covered next year.
-
The same drug may be in a higher cost tier under another plan.
-
Plans can require step therapy or quantity limits, adding complexity.
You should always check whether your medications are included in a plan’s current formulary—not just assume coverage based on the plan name or reputation.
Tiered Pricing Isn’t Always Straightforward
Most Medicare Part D plans use a tiered pricing model, typically with five or six tiers:
-
Preferred generic
-
Generic
-
Preferred brand
-
Non-preferred brand
-
Specialty drugs
-
Select-care (if applicable)
Each tier comes with different copayments or coinsurance. For example, you might pay a fixed amount for Tier 1 but a percentage of the drug’s cost for Tier 5.
Where it gets tricky is that two plans may place the same drug in different tiers. That could mean paying $10 per month in one plan—or $100 in another.
Network Pharmacies Vary More Than You Think
Not every plan uses the same pharmacy network, and even within networks, certain pharmacies are classified as “preferred.” Using a non-preferred or out-of-network pharmacy can result in higher costs—or no coverage at all.
As of 2025, most plans still allow mail-order pharmacy services, but delivery times, refills, and covered drugs can differ. It’s also worth checking:
-
Are your local pharmacies considered preferred?
-
Does the plan cover out-of-state refills if you travel?
-
Are 90-day prescriptions available for maintenance drugs?
These details affect your convenience and cost.
Cost-Sharing Rules Are Changing—But Not Uniformly
The introduction of the $2,000 annual out-of-pocket cap in 2025 is a major shift. Once you hit this limit, you won’t pay anything more for covered medications during the year.
However, how quickly you reach that threshold depends on:
-
Plan premiums and deductibles
-
Coinsurance or copays per tier
-
Your medication needs and tier assignments
Some plans may frontload costs, with high deductibles followed by lower copays. Others may have no deductible but higher tiered copays. Always look at:
-
Annual deductible: Maximum allowed is $590 in 2025.
-
Coinsurance percentages for brand-name or specialty drugs.
-
Tier assignments for your medications.
Not All Supplemental Benefits Are Equal
Some Medicare Part D plans offer extras like medication therapy management (MTM), 24/7 pharmacy helplines, or enhanced drug coverage.
However, these are not standardized:
-
One plan may offer MTM for anyone with chronic conditions.
-
Another may limit the service to those on specific medications.
-
Some include tools for pill reminders or digital health apps; others don’t.
These extras can add value, but you’ll need to look beyond the marketing and evaluate whether the services apply to your situation.
Plan Ratings Provide Clues—but Not the Whole Picture
Each Medicare Part D plan receives a Star Rating from CMS (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) based on quality, customer satisfaction, and performance.
While ratings from 1 to 5 stars help filter options, they don’t show:
-
How well a plan covers your specific drugs
-
What it will actually cost you based on usage
-
Whether your preferred pharmacy is included
Use star ratings as a starting point, not the final decision-maker.
Changes Can Happen Every Year—Stay Updated
Even if you’re currently enrolled in a plan that works for you, that could change in 2026. Each fall, Medicare beneficiaries receive an Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) from their plan. It outlines any upcoming modifications in:
-
Premiums and deductibles
-
Drug coverage and tiers
-
Pharmacy networks
-
Supplemental benefits
You should always review your ANOC and compare it with other available options during the Medicare Open Enrollment Period (October 15 to December 7).
Avoiding the Pitfalls of Auto-Renewal
If you don’t make a change during the Open Enrollment window, your plan will automatically renew. But that might not serve your best interest if:
-
Your medications have changed
-
The plan’s formulary dropped a covered drug
-
Your pharmacy is no longer in-network
-
You’ve crossed into a higher usage level, making your current plan costlier
Set a reminder each fall to review your coverage options, costs, and plan changes—even if you’re happy with your current plan.
You Can Switch Plans Every Year—Here’s How
You don’t have to stick with one Part D plan forever. During the annual Open Enrollment Period, you can:
-
Switch from one Part D plan to another
-
Drop Part D if you’re joining a Medicare Advantage plan that includes drug coverage
-
Rejoin Part D if you’re returning to Original Medicare
Changes you make during this window take effect on January 1 of the following year. Be sure to compare plans based on your actual medications and preferred pharmacy network.
Informed Decisions Start with the Right Questions
When evaluating Medicare Part D plans in 2025, ask yourself:
-
Are all my prescriptions covered?
-
What tier is each drug in, and what’s the cost?
-
Do I prefer a pharmacy that’s in the plan’s network?
-
Will I reach the $2,000 out-of-pocket cap quickly?
-
Are there any extra benefits I’ll actually use?
-
Does the plan have restrictions like prior authorization or quantity limits?
These questions reveal how well a plan fits—not just how it looks on paper.
Your Prescription Coverage Is Too Important to Rush
The choices you make around Medicare Part D affect your health and your wallet. Don’t assume all plans are alike just because they meet the same federal standards. In reality, the differences in coverage, costs, pharmacy access, and drug tiers are often significant.
Use the tools available on Medicare’s official website, and for personalized help, get in touch with a licensed agent listed on this website. They can walk you through your options based on the prescriptions you take and where you live.
